< Back to IRCAM Forum

Spat5.reverb~ @channels 6 FEEDBACK BUG

Here is a patch sending the same signal to spat5.reverb~ @channels 6 and to spat5.reverb~ @channels 8. After 10 seconds, spat5.reverb~ @channels 6 goes to feedback, whereas spat5.reverb~ @channels 8 sounds normal.
I am using spat 5.1.5, Max 8.1.1 and macOS 10.14.6
Nicolas


----------begin_max5_patcher----------
3739.3oc6cs0iqhiD94t+UfxyYZ4KfA1m1YzJMurizJsOrOz6nVjfSZlCAxx
k9zmczL+1WiMPLfgXRfbR2KcKkNGLfKW0mKJ6p9376O9vpMwuSSWY7WLd13g
G98Ge3A9gJNvCk+6GVcv68sgdo7Sa013CGnQYqVKZKi9dl33gA+mbZhQZdhw
AZVRrAMyvKKiF4mPe5eG8i4FahyyL7oFPfQJcabjOMcsQ5QuLqmRnuQS17mF
+0su5EEQCSMHFG8RxLnQF6nT+Mda+B6lz2I6XPSyLhhSN3E9uiD+9i49AwFo
YdY4oFllP.XsAxhr1.hbVaDytE9IAuQqFHgAQLYJOhOZrKOXT9gfnPZFenCO
cP1.o5nfxixjrsuFDs+kD51LgBEa49Dnn+rJ9iIBw+W.vS.ies7pB74Ju3M+
1O.gqJN1e73iEerVSywFd+RSpFFu4kD4cfxaiqsdIH5Xd1KLyy1uTeRAzu9V
PZvlfvfruIO1h2sKkVJ9fBwUVXCi29Epueh29zsIwggxCe98O60j378uJebZ
j2lP5qcu.QCu0sgM6OD6Sabj3De1HTVYmPSYfPurf3HIENwoPjs4BNT7Ga6m
v1V0CAkFT46V+F5piROrg523x6Z4sEFdLWDP.zSVsM7hab12NREWwpzf8QdL
EgBjgKYkbWITEOTCHdX0tfvhoDoMk+GV4c7nzgeP5RJPQ+VL+F4rt9PAQhCA
qODapVP6aK69lvFvYrQadh.o8Nwb0oaCy7kDkGvuFwAY34RQhibKPnLv4VwE
W.vqZ9jJzEym0fsD+wkv+iM5jNr.pHfjRPCll8HMhg4UaSeXkOcmWdX1K6hi
xRC9ubQ.BeBnp8ckhnxFqml8iIALCW0orOIvONpPHZzsEGtp6dlgEDtBjGL7
yHx6nhKlABX5kdZT3gaiWBeFcHuGPUMlEGG1ro5wRHcWVYyGCXtQapEyhO1e
iIA6ecfqcSLqwCCcu4sj9Rdjn0WXfhrWR8dSXMrpOQuvvH5WYC+V2+28hBN3
kQyBD1.DntwNNbfMa4MEs3yP4aoeMvOS36RFMvN8fiUnnU0lY+f8rG4z7XYL
GiMORZ12DZcoCkW4x9kL5gigrQQySnwSjkmxJ+nfFGu0iDJ0XqO0b8CoCi8X
OJMZubi8LQnOuk86Yr9todlQOtJQBmjD9mV7Y4Hnz7BkNK4igFmhj6R6UUGl
+rzR+OWnxj4nJ0aOUo1DZ.9d9qrL0H5ExEXcQyp00U3uCxernC5bl2dMsjoz
zxG7q5Sg.zRgnXHaxGqkO52p5yKb.ijkupPukcWvOeVjzuK8z1IQ6HjQ4tQN
zxbaa..XCAVqFu+BvYvL1BE3PZP43l+tohZtTnl9FBNbLOLkZj9p2wFdO5Iz
UQDAHt+OWLe1haqw7k3ntuvfF1nL5o4PaHWjcbGP9kcQiVcirC7khpi9Wr3L
9B0L+no9sJCmzY.wWV6ClRs+.gavF9rnU8MRa5H46bDGPyROKh.Or0Kji9el
j0jFuAa4EAogA90KoWCuFbejPw3wBzZjr0KxOf8A0rZY8lXWDjTr1dBzk.b3
qx2FX43vmAz3p60fTeasqtsN1NlXXwMCw9K1t3aPSKfqha6Qp2W1FGJVtIWl
bc.X20J+V6KlAmXBESsIsOEc5.sm4IG4iPw2PvD6AxZ08RsR.Wc5HW.Smxkd
HzlXU7Malx.QF3psptZqBMnYw03frMs3JSttDqXD1KxtzMLDw8DXd9nOV2Fd
WKYN0pgSxiICpvsOVECUXWIaydIMHr1uJTnFsT2SjpdxFW7CWgisPtbsgsiC
BaoDITuDKkfST0csBHxrPLLEBU7MrEwgnPyV4ahX1yLdRSOLILuOYr0yIVfI
2a9sw+JeS29y6oEyIblJhF.6nmm0V67UassEdJ8uFF7F8oM4YYL2B8DaaOmR
etfw7IahPdrp9TOen56j5Lq4vwV7Lev.Rg9OQy5r3aYwoXaa7ewKKKIfoznm
9Vpj4PxdTnrCyow6jaVtc4tLLNZuJCyyveURFabIGJev.rm1SeMNIaj2SJyZ
Tp0h2sqveYgA6W64rqzwnSMWibk+5TAmyh2uOjNHbt6ozCb1z9tAMKBm85Qy
N2wnYgcYZQym8ddeilYBmTFAThl6dJClPHNZlflKzL5LAkgwRv4dDCkwjsKL
1Kqebs6cCt9.SGx6P4.NNCxWXCG.kFDEjwh3P83Q8bD...5UDJuekAp.ZsLo
yMo5rhaksqutOm080wpdClKMPXihzyyTAqte1n3Re9hEvPrlfz.PLUE23o7s
Urk48jmEt7UztZ8bZbdx1JYPjwA1xIZHG9zzrfnZmGOWs807ySKq7XkABQWg
vZNkBKMkBVT8ynTXpqTzUocpVC9NKZ39EM37HZ5BflSXbwS0zSJJTjv4RJbF
iTLa5Bx8vjIE.Q0RArWgPthMZr4Z7sQp5Ct69GOcoirRnZ7.Oo8f1f5kD9sW
7h7eYaXdZ1oZkRip6xYfp6RjMSLnbCjEaEKRiZ7Y8j7MUUJD5+CKTHLQram.
9tc5.4QaaVDz8EUnPfuOEJD5ZJTHzbTnPvkBE5SdgBMTdS8iyY5fefuCyFYw
FEnIirWoUET6WCh7i+5zt0y5mCzM4aTrFWUaHsi6SHGKa.AT9iEyIcYB.ghp
MB2elRI2pzT+IQcahrexxFZZBcK+g4QVWkMBN4az+dufn+bvsRpyYzP44HWh
ULWOkEbdckVMPQB0HcTk0od6aYOoxm8CDVgWKxuFRTRQXXmBH+FDmwZ4MiZc
gZKs0lRsKdK64J7UmnH0oRoXtJ+v8WKOf6t8z5GrAiXWs3vomMO614Rzaapz
eSpLlj8kx7659RIX2AOb8Fj6XZc64d8UZivkF11piyNsy14zM2Tq5hSLUQDd
nFySFLm12X7P4h1tZDgybhHpBo.ayC2.ApfDV2UXB2OFXhYpxbKMUR0mKFbk
Emf4cT84NMUeqPIgQvAzRxYg5SmBvwZTJ.33JQazG.MPU7lZqBviREf+HnBr
FIJXbNBL+HnBbGIJfLJUf0G.U.BMRTf8nTAjOBp.xHQANiREX+QPE3NRTf6n
TAN2prTqal0ly7CWHC15jKI2YVHH5HDNyrPXoiPXOyBgoNBAYlEBrNBg4LKD
HcDB7LKDPcDBzLJDlWc5dudYnXe.0RHbmag.poP.mSg.ooPflSg.qoPfmSgv
TSgvbNEBKMEBq4THHZJDj4THr0THrmKgPWeUf4zOgtdsAyoeBce9EXN8Sn6S
xAyoeBcioALm9IzM5Nvb5mP23bAyoeBci3GzqehSqFhmnpdVNzocsu3E+0+j
m27W9EZT9oUcUUVNpE8M62EDFVmASU6Ad0FCuRbVRoTaUiLehbMgPdROwkb+
j8M1WrrZ4pn75f0zf0xzEvImnIofwk7uUv8Qbm7lVdontLOECbc.lhuojglO
rxKZeYA.0J8lqNlDeLNotZndB6135xyh2m34GTtjV0I.XsDZIgclcqtkh0tW
vzY46gJzVsQ8uIrbFP3OEG5a7OhK1l9.cMsx4H5YdVhjAZyn39Kl+8qQFauw
DhWyKM.Z8azAO4X04MXPkD9bY1sLJTmqtcZiqzxA9bpUjSV6UgRFiOr54w86
NBaSLs4JMbMyzMU3N4J7Dosg6p7gI4l5Ll9Uc.GUE24yMCdaNQDduaO1IJKV
9yZ4mUa2usYykMG1cYJ7zOEdVM0eQ7ZB4eUTZ65Zy6+Mhw7GLhnDa9ovbp9O
mwa6VVm2vxhgEPI9qMl5nTcKQW2pAwOmPoQW0nP7NHo9cLBj3vBz9lL.xOrg
l7yr.KtJ4uPgC3yurbQPKwaYG44WW+fX7z0oj0Imohh98KoV46i9E6Ci23EV
Vg70J45KSv2iWN6.naI4e4LPpSAE2S4FehEwJqPsgpz3UIzP1JmeiNv6o3pC
qnpiUxiI.gERrMzDU9YwDCSj7KQYXwaEhaDslFrbiuhRMVNCs3Szjp2JLVip
KtBO2tphqoN0YplXMpjXqSUR7vUQrVUPrFUO7PUN7YpZ3x.rlRx606668U03
AUdGTOsRYQe1eAeNDm+bDui8Lws4o9Mr1NUUFh55At+Z479g5kjALCN2LlWp
jkkfEZVtPyxEZVtPyxEd+sPyxEZVd0zrjbwzrzsGVVRFVAhEuEtPxuHfmYdU
tvgxwwgR7BGJmPNTRlVeZ1SEGJgXxndIwtPQRMoH4EYvIyoAuLb.no02QK9B
AHWH.4BAHWH.4BAHWH.4BAHuGI.4mZpusP3qEBec2Q3qExVsP1pExVcWSGxE
ZNsPyoOozbZgbOKj6YgbOKj6YgbOKj6YgbOKj6YgbOKSgWH2yB4dVH2yB4d9
HRtGkU3NYRX1iqBh8LPUxibdhH+SwT4Jd8TVL2yGudlcN7.AeXHwCZgDOpHw
CYLj3gnbFg8EQhGmaIGdTxfD37vWGdW0LuoB6V680qz50MeTM9ebtd1LOTi7
E05+UB6.Yl1tVcOCtpdFI+FJpmN17zKmnqpeHZzOjIne.ZzOfInefZzOvIne
PZzOnInevZzO3IneL0neLmf9wRi9w5J6GSMva3I.uYpAdCOA3MSMva3I.uYp
AdCOA3MSMva3I.uYpAdCOQ3MhF8yU6GEnAvFNENRAZfrgSgmTfFPa3T3JEnA
1FNE9RAZ.tgSgyTfFna3Dftg5.5.S.pCpCnCLAnNnNfNvDf5f5.5.S.pCpCn
CLAnNnNfNPGTmXc.sXadQezhk4sXXdW1k2Oyxaypb91D0JE9hw5YRceq8HqT
SnXexqVKj5zzeIon+BSO+Eta5p2O79SIeOoiuZAeqer+89q499IC7zJk6pMI
8kl8ISTpSmt98u7h7u3DEe1jDOkivKPSC9XNRq1jiQaM0Yte6biM97hcoyhu
n7go8b+la49fovVc5qmNKXmzTe4dp+jaslD8dcJl0Y9h6xzE8mtLIlmtoEVs
cRiTAe0xR2T9pVVtzz7NQBXiz4psDdtT3d8BWmT0psroU5YGm.JBUum2BSO9
GO9+.aig.JC
-----------end_max5_patcher-----------

Thanks for the very clear report.

This one will be difficult to fix.
I would strongly recommend to use @channels 8.

Best,
T.

00